If you’re a homeowner in New Jersey, chances are you’ll need roofing help eventually — whether it’s a small repair, a leak after a storm, or a full replacement. But with so many roofing contractors out there (and a few shady operators in the mix), figuring out how to find a good roofing company can feel like a real challenge. As the owner of a roofing company, I’ve been helping New Jersey homeowners navigate this decision since 1999. So, how do you find a reputable roofing company and avoid the headaches that come with scams? Here’s what you need to know.
Ask Around and Read Reviews
Referrals are gold. Ask friends, family, and neighbors if they’ve worked with a roofer they’d recommend. These first-hand experiences are often more valuable than any ad or flyer. Don’t forget to check online reviews too — sites like Google and the Better Business Bureau can give you a sense of how the company treats its customers and stands by its work. For instance, you can check out our Google reviews to see what local homeowners are saying about their experience with Powell’s Roofing.
Check Licensing and Insurance
This step is non-negotiable. Always ask for proof of proper licensing and insurance. If you’re wondering, “How do I find a reputable roofing company that’s actually legit?” — this is key. Legitimate roofers will have no problem showing documentation, and it protects you in case there’s an accident or property damage.
Get Everything in Writing
A reputable company won’t shy away from putting the details in writing. That means a clear, itemized estimate, a timeline, and a payment schedule. Be wary of vague promises, handshake deals, or anyone pushing you to pay in full upfront. If you’re comparing options and not sure how to choose a good roofing company, look at how transparent and thorough they are when answering your questions.
Know the Warning Signs
Sadly, roofing scams are more common than most homeowners realize. According to the Better Business Bureau, 15% of all home improvement scam reports since 2015 have been roof-related projects, making roofing one of the most targeted areas for fraud. Some of the most frequent scams in New Jersey, Union County, and throughout Central Jersey include:
- Door-to-door “storm chasers” who show up right after a storm, claiming you have urgent damage and pressuring you to sign up for repairs on the spot
- Deposit scams, where a contractor asks for a hefty deposit up front, then disappears — or keeps coming up with excuses to delay the work
- Unlicensed or uninsured contractors who may offer cheap prices but leave you exposed to liability, poor workmanship, or unfinished jobs
- Inflated damage claims—some roofers will exaggerate the scope of storm damage or recommend unnecessary repairs, hoping your insurance company (or you) will just pay up
- Overcharging for simple repairs or using subpar materials while billing you for premium ones
If you notice high-pressure sales tactics, requests for large cash deposits, or a contractor who won’t provide credentials or a physical address, take it as a red flag.
Why Local Roots Matter (and Why Powell’s is Here for You)
Your best bet is to look for good roofing companies near me with a solid, local presence. A reputable roofing company should have a physical address in New Jersey and a track record you can actually check. Out-of-state contractors or those who just roll into town after a storm are usually best avoided. Local NJ roofing contractors know the area, the climate, and the building codes—so you get expertise that’s actually relevant to your home in Garwood, Westfield, Cranford, and surrounding Union County communities.
That’s exactly what we offer at Powell’s Roofing & Siding. We’ve been serving New Jersey homeowners since 1999, building our reputation one project at a time. Our small, owner-operated business is located right here in Garwood, and we’ve earned industry distinctions including an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau and Super Service Awards from Angie’s List. Whether you need advice, a second opinion, or a free estimate, we’re always here to help—no pressure, just honest answers from a team you can trust. Reach out today if you want to make sure your roofing project is in good hands.
